Vol. IV No. 1 February 1999
 An Activity of The Committee for the Fourth R


FINANCING OF POLITICAL CAMPAIGNS
.....THE TOPIC FOR DISCUSSION, BEGINNING MARCH 1

"How should our political campaigns be financed?" This often-debated but never-resolved question will be the subject for the next C.L.U.R.T. discussion series, at the Lakewood Public Library for six Monday evenings beginning March 1. Beginning time is 7:15.

Three meetings will be in the Auditorium and three will be in the basement Meeting Room. Two Mondays (March 22 and April 12) are left open, and the group will either recess on those dates or meet elsewhere. The schedule is:
 

March 1 -- Auditorium March 29 -- Auditorium
March 8 -- Meeting Room April 5 -- Meeting Room
March 15 -- Auditorium April 19 -- Meeting Room
Having six or more sessions will allow discussions to be carried over from one session to the next. Issues raised in one session can be examined during the intervening week and addressed at the following session. This accords with the purpose of the series, which is to put into practice the principles of reasoned discussion - laying out arguments, identifying issues, clarifying meanings, making distinctions and evaluating and criticizing assumptions. The leader will be Gordon Brumm, Ph.D., former philosophy instructor.

The topic of health care came in second in the selection of a topic, and it will become the subject of discussion in the unlikely event that campaign finance is exhausted as a subject. Other topics seriously considered were bioethics and welfare.

The meetings are free and open to residents of all communities and all ages. Students are welcome. However, the enrollment is limited. To register, or for information, call 226-6105.


CFFR on Lakewood Library Web site
If you want to see what the Committee for the Fourth "R" is doing, or if you want to see the issues that C.L.U.R.T. discussions have raised, you can do so through the Lakewood Public Library web site. The address is www.lkwdpl.org. Look down the right-hand column of organizations and click on "Committee for the Fourth 'R'."


PREVIOUS SERIES: PUBLIC SCHOOL FUNDING

"Should funding of Ohio public schools be restructured? If so, how?" This was the subject of eight meetings stretching from September 28 through November.

Six positions or plans were put forth, each emphasizing one or another of the three basic themes, basic/minimum education, equality and choice:

1) Basic for all. Each student is to receive state funding sufficient for a basic education, as determined by a board of experts. Individual districts, however, may use local resources to augment state revenues. The rationale is that the overall good of the state as a whole (the "conglomerate") would be served thereby. As the name implies, the idea of a basic minimum education is the foundation of this position.

2) Equal for all. Each student is to get the same state funding, and the level of funding is determined by the voters. Individual districts may not buy a better education for their own students. This plan aims not only for equality but also for a sense of community, a "one for all, all for one" feeling which will be advanced by insuring that each family may increase funding for its own children only by increasing funding for all.

3) Robin Hood (modeled after the current Texas system.). Wealthier school districts are required to transfer funds to the poorer school districts. Equality is the foundation.

4) Libertarian. All public support for the schools should be discontinued, leaving students to rely on private or charitable resources. The rationale is that public schools are inefficient and that absence of public education would mean greater challenges which would lead to greater accomplishments.

5) Present system adjusted. Money received from the state should be sufficient to allow school districts to meet the mandates of the legislature. To accomplish this, business property taxes should be levied by the state and distributed on a regional or statewide basis.

6) Status quo. The present system is not to be changed. Choice -- the choice of a family to move from one district to another and the choice of a district as to its level of funding -- was a key consideration for this position.

Although issues were not so prominent in the discussions as the explanations of the plans themselves, a number of basic issues arose, such as:

For a fuller summary, go to the Lakewood Public Library web site and click on "Committee for the Fourth 'R'."


Political-positions Group

What is a conservative? A liberal? A socialist? A libertarian? What are the various issues on which individuals may disagree? These are the questions addressed by a group discussing political positions. The group has recessed after four meetings, but will resume. For information, call 226-6105.



THE C.L.U.R.T. VIEWPOINT
C.L.U.R.T. is an activity of The Committee for the Fourth "R," dedicated to the belief that: reasoning together is important both in helping us to arrive at well justified positions and in helping us to understand on e another; whether reasoning is done well or badly is independent of the particular opinions one appeals to; and good reasoning needs to be promoted in every way and in every possible place - in the schools, in the media and especially in the minds of citizens.

To be put on the mailing list for this newsletter, call 216-226-6106.



Previous Newsletter
Committee for the Fourth R
Lakewood Public Library