1986
| Dr. Proctor Jones* | 1934 |
| William Schaufele | 1942 |
| Dr. Donald Henderson | 1946 |
| Gov. Richard Celeste | 1955 |
| Dr. John Palomaki | 1964 |
1987
| MitchellDarling* | 1934 |
| Harry Figgie Jr. | 1941 |
| Herbert Gold | 1942 |
| Jack Buck | 1942 |
| Marge Redmond | 1942 |
1988
| Dr. James Miller | 1932 |
| J. Maurice Struchen | 1938 |
| Dr. Dorothy Soule | 1941 |
| Mary Lou Ferbert | 1942 |
| Nicholas Lesko | 1942 |
1989
| Viola Famiana Columbi* | 1932 |
| Thomas A. Read* | 1939 |
| Donald Erb | 1945 |
| James R. Barker | 1953 |
| Richard Mueller | 1967 |
1990
| Carlyn Meeker Irwin* | 1922 |
| Omar S. Ranney* | 1924 |
| Robert C. Coplan | 1935 |
| Hatten Yoder | 1938 |
| Mary Beth McKenzie | 1964 |
1991
| W. Charles Geiger II* | 1938 |
| Kinley Shogren* | 1942 |
| Dr. John Papp | 1956 |
| Jeff Gall | 1968 |
| Dee Hoty | 1970 |
1992
| Alvino Rey | 1927 |
| Fr. Joseph O. Schell | 1931 |
| Robert C. Weber | 1948 |
| Emily Fitzgibbon Toth | 1961 |
| Kathy Conry | 1966 |
1993
| Chuck Heaton | 1934 |
| Robert Hitz* | 1935 |
| Peggy Sonenfield Streit | 1941 |
| Dr. Kathryn Huxtable Lewis | 1952 |
| Fred W. Leick | 1961 |
1994
| Dorothy Schaefer Teare* | 1924 |
| Harold F. Gilbert | 1934 |
| Albert L. Zesiger | 1947 |
| Dr. Jacob F. Palomaki | 1960 |
| Dr. Stewart L. Tubbs | 1961 |
1995
| Alan Oatey | 1944 |
| D. Rusty Brown | 1947 |
| Dr. John Pasalis | 1957 |
| John Pasquin | 1963 |
| David Louie | 1968 |
1996
| James Doty | 1940 |
| Albert Hausmann | 1950 |
| Janis Fichter Purdy | 1966 |
| Dr. Daniel DiBiasio | 1967 |
| Dr. Richard Freeman | 1965 |
1997
| Dr. John Sanders | 1934 |
| Jack Norris | 1945 |
| Marilyn Garrett Zack | 1946 |
| Donald Strang Jr. | 1956 |
| Ronald Tober | 1965 |
1998
| Judge Robert Lawther | 1945 |
| Dr. Don Buckeye | 1949 |
| Dr. James Baker | 1953 |
| Dr. Kent Reinke | 1961 |
| Sally Eyerdam* | 1963 |
1999
| Jane Sapp Scott | 1937 |
| Jack Tanis | 1944 |
| Phillip Ranney | 1954 |
| Dave Deming | 1962 |
| Bob DiBiasio | 1973 |
2000
| John F. Lipaj | 1941 |
| George Read | 1944 |
| Edward Saxton | 1947 |
| Amy Campbell | 1971 |
| David Conte | 1973 |
2001
| Robert Hull | 1949 |
| Lee Munder | 1963 |
| James Tetlow | 1973 |
| Deidre Depke | 1980 |
| Joanne VanBurik | 1982 |
2002
| LouAnn Bauer Fletcher | 1947 |
| Judge John Milligan | 1946 |
| Carrie Schopf, M.D. | 1956 |
| Sean Flynn | 1982 |
| Frank Krasovic | 1961 |
2003
| Eugene N. Borza | 1953 |
| David L. Baker | 1944 |
| Kenneth Bell | 1948 |
| Janet S. Duff* | 1946 |
| Arthur Farr | 1937 |
2004
| Alida H. Struze | 1938 |
| William Huffman | 1936 |
| William Vigrass | 1948 |
| Mary Nixon | 1952 |
| Mike Summers | 1972 |